SA Cold-Chain Delivery (0–3°C)
5% Off Bank Transfer & PayID
Wholesale Accounts
Back to All Articles
Meat Guides8 min readOctober 2026

Steak Cuts Explained: Scotch Fillet, Porterhouse, T-Bone, Rump and More

Author: Ponde Meats Butcher Team·Ponde Meats, Cowirra SA

A butcher’s plain-English guide to the most popular Australian steak cuts, how each one eats, and exactly how to cook it.

Walk into any steakhouse or butcher and the choices can feel overwhelming: scotch fillet, porterhouse, T-bone, rump, tomahawk, eye fillet. Australian butchers use some names that are different from those in other countries, and the same steak may be sold under several labels. Knowing what each cut is, where it comes from, how it eats and how to cook it makes shopping easier and your steak dinners better. This guide explains the most popular steak cuts you will find at Ponde Meats, with clear advice on how to cook each one.

Where steaks come from

Most steaks come from the parts of the animal that do the least work, along the back. The rib section, the short loin and the sirloin provide the tenderest cuts, while the rump and the shoulder produce more flavourful but firmer ones. As a general rule, the less a muscle works, the more tender it is, and the more fat marbling it has, the richer the flavour and juiciness.

Scotch fillet (ribeye)

Scotch fillet is cut from the rib section, and is one of the most popular steaks in Australia. It is heavily marbled, with a rich, buttery flavour, and it contains a spiral of fat in the centre that renders as it cooks. It is called ribeye in many other countries. A bone-in version is called a rib eye on the bone or OP rib, and a very thick bone-in cut with a long bone is the tomahawk.

To cook scotch fillet, season well, sear over high heat for three to four minutes per side, and rest for five minutes. Its generous fat makes it forgiving, so it suits both grilling and pan-frying. It is a good choice for people who prioritise flavour and juiciness.

Porterhouse (striploin, New York strip)

Porterhouse, called sirloin or New York strip in other countries, is cut from the short loin, and has a firm, fine texture with a strip of fat along one edge. It is less marbled than scotch fillet, with a cleaner beef flavour and a satisfying chew. It is a classic steakhouse cut, popular for its consistency and neat shape.

Cook it similarly to scotch fillet, but note that it is slightly leaner, so avoid overcooking. Leave the fat strip on during cooking, since it bastes the meat, and trim it afterwards if you prefer. Medium-rare is ideal.

T-bone

The T-bone is two steaks in one, with a strip of porterhouse on one side of the T-shaped bone and a piece of tenderloin, or eye fillet, on the other. This gives you the contrast of tender and robust in a single steak, and the bone adds flavour. T-bones are substantial, usually four hundred to five hundred grams or more, and they make a great shared steak.

Because the fillet cooks faster than the strip, position the steak so that the fillet side is away from the hottest part of the grill. Cook for four to five minutes per side for medium-rare, then rest. The bone makes it a little trickier to carve, but cutting along the bone and slicing each side separately works well.

Eye fillet (tenderloin)

The eye fillet is the most tender steak, taken from the tenderloin, a long, narrow muscle that sits under the spine. It has very little fat, a delicate flavour and a texture that is often described as buttery. Because it is lean, it benefits from a sauce or a wrap of bacon, and it is best cooked rare to medium-rare. Overcooking makes it dry.

Cut into thick medallions, sear over high heat for three minutes per side, and finish with butter, garlic and thyme. It is a good choice for people who value tenderness above all, and for special-occasion dinners. A whole tenderloin can also be roasted, as in a beef Wellington.

Rump

Rump comes from the hindquarter, and it is a lean, flavourful steak with a firm texture and a strong beefy taste. It is more affordable than premium steaks, and it is a favourite for those who prefer flavour over tenderness. The rump cap, or picanha, has a thick fat cover that is highly prized in Brazilian barbecue.

For the best results, marinate rump for a few hours, cook it hot and fast to medium-rare, and slice thinly across the grain. Avoid cooking it beyond medium, as it can become tough. A bit of care turns it into a great-value steak.

Tomahawk

The tomahawk is a thick-cut scotch fillet with a long rib bone left on, creating a dramatic presentation. It has the same marbling and flavour as scotch fillet, and the bone adds richness. Tomahawks are large, usually one and a quarter to one and a half kilograms, and are best shared. The reverse sear method, cooking slowly first and searing at the end, gives the most even result.

Other cuts worth knowing

  • Thick skirt: a loose-textured, flavourful cut that needs fast cooking and thin slicing.
  • Flank: a lean, long-grained steak that suits marinating and slicing for fajitas and salads.
  • Oyster blade: an economical shoulder steak with a line of gristle, good for braising or marinated grilling.
  • Chuck steak: robust and affordable, best slow cooked.

Comparing the steaks

If you want maximum tenderness, choose eye fillet. If you want rich marbling and juiciness, choose scotch fillet. If you want classic steakhouse balance, choose porterhouse. If you want the best of both worlds in one steak, choose a T-bone. If you want big flavour at a good price, choose rump. If you want a showpiece to share, choose a tomahawk. There is no single best steak; it depends on your preferences and budget.

Grain-fed versus pasture-fed

Some of our steaks are labelled as grain fed for one hundred days. Extended grain feeding tends to produce more marbling and a milder, richer flavour, while pasture-fed beef often has a leaner, more distinct beef flavour. Neither is better in every case; it comes down to taste. Our MSA-graded options carry an eating-quality grade from the Meat Standards Australia program, which scores beef on tenderness, juiciness and flavour.

How to cook the perfect steak

The principles are the same for most steaks. Bring the steak to room temperature for twenty to thirty minutes. Pat it dry, season with salt, and oil the meat rather than the pan. Cook on a very hot surface, turning once or twice, and avoid constantly flipping. Use a thermometer to check doneness: around 50 degrees for rare, 54 to 56 for medium-rare, 60 for medium, before resting. Rest for five to ten minutes, and serve.

Thickness matters

A steak that is two and a half to three centimetres thick is ideal for most cooking methods, because it allows a good crust without overcooking the centre. Thinner steaks cook quickly and are harder to get right, while very thick steaks benefit from the reverse sear. When ordering steaks in bulk, specify the thickness you prefer, so each steak cooks as you expect.

Quick-reference guide to doneness

Doneness is a matter of taste, but knowing the numbers helps you cook consistently. Rare steaks reach about 50 degrees Celsius, with a cool red centre. Medium-rare, at 54 to 56 degrees, has a warm red centre and is the most popular choice for tender cuts. Medium, at 60 to 63 degrees, has a pink centre and a firmer texture. Medium-well and well-done steaks, above 65 degrees, are grey throughout and much drier, which is not recommended for lean cuts such as eye fillet and rump. Remember that the steak will rise a few degrees as it rests, so remove it from the heat slightly earlier than your target.

Seasoning and sauces

Good steaks need little more than salt. Season generously, either at least forty minutes ahead or just before cooking. Black pepper is best added after cooking, since it can burn in a very hot pan. Finish with a knob of butter, garlic and thyme, or serve with a sauce. Classic options include peppercorn sauce, mushroom sauce, béarnaise, red wine jus, chimichurri and blue cheese butter. Match the intensity of the sauce to the steak: delicate eye fillet suits a light sauce, while bold rump and scotch fillet can handle something stronger.

Serving sizes and sides

Plan for around two hundred to three hundred grams of boneless steak per person, or four hundred to five hundred grams for bone-in cuts such as T-bones and OP rib. For sides, classic choices include chips, creamy mash, roasted vegetables, a green salad, grilled corn or steamed greens. For a lighter meal, serve sliced steak over a salad with a sharp dressing. Always rest the meat before serving, and serve on warm plates so that the steak stays hot while you eat.

Cooking steaks for a crowd

When cooking for many people, preparation is everything. Season the steaks in advance, cook them in batches on a very hot plate or grill, and hold them on a rack in a low oven at around 70 degrees while you finish the rest. Pull each steak a little earlier than you would for a single serving, since holding time adds to the cooking. Use a probe thermometer for consistency, and rest the steaks briefly before serving.

Buying steaks from Ponde Meats

Ponde Meats sells sliced and whole steak cuts, including scotch fillet, porterhouse, rib eye on the bone, T-bones, rump and tomahawks, all vacuum sealed and delivered chilled. Whole primals are available for those who like to cut their own steaks, and our butchers can cut to your preferred thickness on request. Orders start at two hundred dollars, free refrigerated delivery applies over one thousand dollars, and bank transfer or PayID customers take five percent off. Call 0485 901 075 for advice on cuts and quantities.

Need a hand choosing cuts or quantities?

Our Cowirra butchers will cut to your instructions and advise on sizes for your family, event or kitchen. Call 0485 901 075 or message us on WhatsApp.