Tomahawk Steak: The Reverse Sear Method, Step by Step
How to cook a thick tomahawk steak evenly from edge to edge using the reverse sear, with oven and barbecue methods, temperatures and carving.
A tomahawk steak is a showstopper. Thick, richly marbled and crowned with a long, exposed rib bone, it arrives at the table looking like something from a medieval feast. It is also one of the more demanding cuts to cook, because its thickness makes it easy to burn on the outside before the inside is ready. The solution, used by steakhouse chefs and barbecue enthusiasts everywhere, is the reverse sear: cook the steak gently first, then finish with a blistering sear. This guide explains how to choose, prepare and cook a tomahawk with the reverse sear method, step by step.
What is a tomahawk?
A tomahawk is a bone-in scotch fillet, or ribeye, with the entire rib bone left attached, usually frenched so that the bone is clean and exposed. It is cut thick, typically five centimetres or more, and weighs between one and a half and two kilograms with the bone. The meat itself is the same marbled, juicy ribeye you know, with a spiral of fat in the centre and a cap of tender meat around it. The bone contributes a little flavour and provides a striking presentation.
Our tomahawks are sold as single steaks of around one and a quarter kilograms, monster steaks of around one and a half kilograms, and twin packs. A single steak feeds two to three people, and a monster feeds three to four.
Why the reverse sear works
The traditional method, searing first and then finishing in the oven, can leave a thick steak with a wide band of overcooked grey meat beneath the surface. The reverse sear flips the order. You cook the steak slowly at a low temperature until it is just below your target, which warms it evenly from edge to edge. Then you sear it very hot to build a dark, flavourful crust. The result is a uniformly pink interior with a thin crust, and far less guesswork.
A bonus is that the low, slow stage dries the surface of the steak slightly, which helps the crust form quickly in the final sear, reducing the time the meat spends over the fire.
Preparing the steak
Remove the tomahawk from the fridge and pat it dry. For the best results, salt the steak generously on all sides at least an hour before cooking, or even the night before, leaving it uncovered on a rack in the fridge. This dry brining seasons the meat deeply and dries the surface. Take it out of the fridge about thirty minutes before cooking so it loses the chill. Season with freshly ground black pepper just before it goes on the heat.
Setting up the oven method
Preheat your oven to 110 to 120 degrees Celsius. Place the tomahawk on a wire rack over a baking tray, so that air circulates all around it. Insert a probe thermometer into the thickest part of the meat, avoiding the bone, and cook until the internal temperature reaches about 48 degrees Celsius for medium-rare. This usually takes forty-five minutes to an hour, depending on thickness. Remove the steak, tent it loosely with foil and let it rest while you heat the pan or grill.
Setting up the barbecue method
If you are using a barbecue, set up two heat zones. Light one side on high and leave the other off, or bank the coals to one side of a kettle. Place the steak on the cool side, with the lid closed and the bone pointing away from the heat, and cook until it reaches about 48 degrees. The temperature of the cool side should be roughly 110 to 130 degrees. Check the temperature after thirty minutes, and again every ten minutes.
The sear
When the steak has reached its target temperature, move it to the hot side of the barbecue or into a very hot cast-iron pan with a little high smoke point oil. Sear for one to two minutes per side, until a dark, caramelised crust forms. Use tongs to hold the steak on its edges, so the fat cap renders and browns. Add a knob of butter, a few garlic cloves and thyme sprigs in the final minute, and baste the steak with the foaming butter. The internal temperature will rise by a few degrees, reaching around 54 to 56 degrees for medium-rare.
Resting
Rest the tomahawk for ten minutes on a board, loosely covered. This is shorter than you might expect, since the reverse sear has already distributed the juices. During the rest, the crust remains crisp and the meat finishes its cooking. Resist the urge to cut early, as the steak will be juicier for the wait.
Carving
Use a sharp knife to cut along the bone, removing the meat in one piece. Then slice the meat across the grain into slices about one centimetre thick. Fan the slices on a board or platter, with the bone alongside for show, and season with flaky salt. Serve any resting juices and butter from the pan over the top. The bone can be gnawed by whoever is lucky enough to claim it.
Temperature guide
- Rare: remove from the oven at about 43 degrees; final temperature around 50 after the sear and rest.
- Medium-rare: remove at about 48 degrees; final temperature 54 to 56.
- Medium: remove at about 53 degrees; final temperature 60 to 63.
- Well-done is not recommended for a prime cut such as this.
What to serve with a tomahawk
Because the steak is the star, keep the sides simple and generous. Crisp potato wedges or triple-cooked chips, a creamy gratin, roasted garlic mushrooms, charred broccolini, grilled asparagus and a fresh green salad all work well. For sauces, try a classic béarnaise, a peppercorn sauce, chimichurri or a blue cheese butter. A bold red wine, such as a South Australian Shiraz or Cabernet, is the traditional partner.
Common mistakes
- Cooking at too high a heat from the start, which burns the outside.
- Not using a thermometer, which makes doneness a guess.
- Not drying the steak before searing, which prevents a good crust.
- Cutting too soon, which wastes juices.
- Forgetting the bone adds weight, and under-ordering for the number of guests.
Cooking on a charcoal grill
Charcoal imparts lovely smoky flavour. Arrange the coals on one side of the grill, and place the steak on the other side with the lid on and vents partially open. Add a chunk of hardwood for smoke if you like. Cook slowly until the steak reaches the target temperature, then sear directly over the coals, taking care with flare-ups. The combination of smoke and fire makes for an unforgettable steak.
Leftovers
If you have leftover tomahawk, which is rare, slice it thinly and serve cold on sandwiches with horseradish and rocket, or warm gently in a pan with a splash of stock for a steak salad. Store in the fridge in an airtight container and use within two days. The bone makes a flavourful addition to a stock.
Buying a tomahawk from Ponde Meats
Ponde Meats supplies tomahawk steaks as single cuts, monster cuts and twin packs, vacuum sealed and delivered chilled. They are a premium, popular line, so please order a few days ahead for holidays and events, and tell us if you have a preferred thickness or bone length. Orders start at two hundred dollars, and free refrigerated delivery applies over one thousand dollars. Pay by bank transfer or PayID and take five percent off. Call 0485 901 075 for help planning the perfect steak night.
Choosing the right tomahawk
When selecting a tomahawk, look for generous marbling, a bright red colour and a thick, even cut of at least four to five centimetres. A well-marbled steak stays juicier and more flavourful through the long, slow stage of the reverse sear. Check that the bone is cleanly frenched and that the cap of meat around the eye is substantial, since the cap is often the most flavourful part. Order a size that suits your equipment as well, since a very large steak may not fit in a small pan or a compact oven.
Entertaining with a tomahawk
A tomahawk makes a memorable centrepiece for a dinner party. Cook it ahead of your guests’ arrival, using the low oven stage while you prepare the sides, then sear it just before serving, so it arrives at the table sizzling. Carve at the table, or in the kitchen, and arrange the slices on a warm platter. Because the steak is shared, it creates a convivial atmosphere, and your guests will remember the occasion. If you are feeding more than four, cook two tomahawks, and keep the second warm in a low oven while you carve the first.
Frequently asked questions
Can I cook a tomahawk entirely in a pan? You can, but the reverse sear in the oven gives more even results. Is a tomahawk worth the price? If you value presentation and the shared experience, yes, though the meat is the same as a thick scotch fillet. How many does it serve? One steak feeds two to three; plan on around four hundred to five hundred grams of meat per person. Can I freeze it? Yes, in the vacuum pack, but fresh is best for premium cuts. Do I need to trim the fat? Leave it on during cooking, and trim afterwards if you wish.
Need a hand choosing cuts or quantities?
Our Cowirra butchers will cut to your instructions and advise on sizes for your family, event or kitchen. Call 0485 901 075 or message us on WhatsApp.
